There have only
ever been two commercially recorded performances of this, Sullivan's first two act comic opera. This recording was made by Pavillion Records in 1986 but never released as the engineers were unhappy with the results at that time. However, members of the Prince Consort felt that the recording should be heard and approached Chris Webster at Sounds on CD who released the recording coupled with the 1894 reworking of the opera, THE CHIEFTAIN.
The recorded sound is very good as one would expect from this label. However, the performance does leave something to be desired. It is a typical Prince Consort production in that it is poorly paced at times, although the casting is better in this work than in some of their other recordings with Richard Bourjo, usually badly miscast in the 'patter' roles, occupying the bass part of Jose. Norma Kinnear is not really strong enough for the part of Inez, but she does the best she can.
David Craig is delightful as Mr Grigg sounding really in character as the 'little man' who gets in way out of his depth. The one quibble I have is that the intro to his first number 'From Rock to Rock' (the most famous number in the show) has been cut, both here and in THE CHIEFTAIN.
The two operas are presented on 2 CD's - VGS 204. Sounds on CD products can be obtained from Christopher Browne in the UK and from 78s2cd in the States, see the links page.
Click the image above to hear part of the Act One Finale.
The record company Hyperion have been very active in recent years recording Sullivan's lesser-known works. Firstly it was THE GOLDEN LEGEND, then THE PRODIGAL SON and BOER WAR TE DEUM. Late last year (2004) Chandos jumped on the band wagon and recorded TRIAL BY JURY and COX AND BOX and this was issued this spring (2005) and a recording of IVANHOE is scheduled for the summer of 2009.
Not too much of a surprise then that they should record THE CONTRABANDISTA. It has to be stated that it is a pity that as much care has not been taken over this recording as was taken over the previous two - Certainly with my copy there is an annoying skip in the first two tracks which reappears at about track 9 - however this only occurs on one of my CD players so I guess the disc is just a little sensitive. The other gripe is that the principals are placed very forward in the Finale Act 1 making Donald Maxwell (Jose) over-prominent in the choral sections.
All this aside it has to be said that this is a magnificent recording and one which hopefully will persuade amateur companies to include the work in their repertoires. The disc filler, THE FORESTERS, is a revelatory bonus.